CNO mkII
(cost no option)
SEAS W18NX001 + T29CF001/T29CF002
Copyright © Troels Gravesen
(view also
CNO-T25)
During crossover
construction for CNO-T25
(T25C003 tweeter), I decided to take a
fresh look at the CNO crossover, thus an mkII
version, providing an overall more balanced
presentation compared to the "up-front"
tuning of the first version. From the feedback on
first version, some people like this tuning,
despite its elevated upper mid presentation,
which may be very engaging, but leaves a few
recordings on the shelf. The version shown here
will make a flat midrange presentation and both
T29CF001 and T29CF002 (Crescendo) tweeters can be
used with minor changes to tweeter attenuation.
The T29CF002 Crescendo
tweeter is one of the most expensive dome
tweeters available. Hence the name,
"cost-no-object", for this modest 24
liter floorstander.
These new SEAS drivers have classic paper
cones, coated on the rear and applied a rough
Nextel coating on the front. Further
specifications at the SEAS website http://www.seas.no/. The finish of the
drivers is second to none. SEAS is also a true
follower of fashion and the magnets are covered
with soft rubber boots.
Having a pair of suitable
test cabs I only needed to make some new
front panels for the drivers. My test cabs have a
max. volume of 31 litres and this made some deep
bass from the W18, although not too well defined.
View cab simulation below. Closing off the lower
sections of the cabs, I have some 24 litres left,
and this is better. Pure math dictates 17 litres,
QB3 alignment, but the W18NX001s can easily
handle 24 litres without loosing control and we
get better low-end extension. The cab width is a
modest 200 mm. View details below.
Before going into details, a little on the sound.
To my ears the sound from these nextel coated
drivers fall between the SEAS Prestige CA and
EXCEL magnesium drivers. This may suggest sound
quality inferior to the magnesium cones. It
isn't. It's as good as the magnesium cones, only
different due to improved responsiveness. I don't
think they beat the magnesium cones in terms of
neutrality, but these Nextel coated paper cones
provide a very neutral, yet vivid sound. The best
of both worlds? Well, only your ears can
tell.
The Nextel drivers were not only made to look
good, but also provide a sound clearly
distinguishable from the average. High-end
drivers built on classic virtues. As always we
apply to the law of diminishing returns when we
buy expensive stuff. Small improvements may cost
small fortunes. I think these nextel units are
the best sounding drivers SEAS has ever built.
|

The rear chamber of
the Crescendo tweeter is one solid cup of die-cast
aluminium, the best I've seen - and felt.
Product
specification files: W18NX001, T29CF001, T29CF002
The crossover
A lot of
simulation work went ahead of actual set-up and
fine-tuning, and both parallel and series
crossovers were tried. The crossover shown below
is a series crossover and was finally chosen for
presentation. Due to drivers' intrinsic
performance and baffle geometry, we have a bump
in the 700-1000 Hz range and an LCR circuit
gently equalises the response here.
For newcomers to series crossovers: These cannot
be bi-wired. Read about series crossovers here: http://sound.westhost.com/parallel-series.htm#3.1
|

CNO series
crossover.
For
T29CF001: R1061 = 5R6-6R8 and R1051 = 5.6 ohms.
R1061: Try it out before deciding!

Suggested crossover
layout for T29CF002 tweeter.
Note: The orientation of components in the LCR circuit
doesn't matter.
It can be LCR, CRL, RCL, etc. Doesn't matter (I have this
question all the time).
Crossover Components

Crossover components from Jantzen Audio.
Kit will contain resitors for both options. Specify
tweeter on order.
e-mail: contact@jantzen-audio.com

The Box

SEAS TS data

LspCAD box
simulation. Port has to be shorter than calculated here,
multiply by 0.7

Bass performance
from 24 litres vented cab, port tuning 40 Hz.
PORTS for Fb = 42 Hz (just to pick something..):
55 mm (ID) x 90 mm (L)
60 mm (ID) x 110 mm (L)
65 mm (ID) x 130 mm (L)
70 mm (ID) x 155 mm (L)
75 mm (ID) x 180 mm (L)
Cabs
should be tilted 5 degrees to render the flattest
frequency response.
Cabinet construction

Same
cabinet as CNO-T25. Click image to download large
drawing.

Test cabs with painted front panel for the benefit of the
photo shoot.
Measurements

Left:
SPL response from drivers without crossover from test
cabinet.
Right: Impedance of drivers mounted in
cabinet.

Left:
Summed response of drivers merged at 350 Hz with bass
nearfield response.
Right: Point of crossover is 3100Hz. Blue =
reverse polarity of tweeter. Reading taken at 1 meter
distance, tweeter height.

Left:
Impedance of final system. Minimum impedance = 6 ohms.
Right: This speaker has excellent vertical
dispersion, here measured at
1 meter distance with microphone from just above tweeter
to just below woofer.

Left: CSD, 20 dB. Right: CSD, 40 dB
SEAS EXCEL T29-tweeters
T29CF001 & T29CF002 Crescendo

SEAS
T29CF002 and -001 tweeters have a different magnet
systems. Read data files at SEAS website. The -001 has a
round neodymium magnet and slightly higher,
un-symmetrical impedance profile, probably due to the
damping system used. The -002 looks better, but that's
about it from my point of view.

Left:
T29CF002 to the left and T29CF001 to the right, showing
differences in magnet construction. The Crescendo - 002 -
has a small damping pad under the dome on top of the foam
plug placed in the centre polepiece hole. Have we seen
this before? The -001 hasn't, thus some irregularities at
18 kHz.
Right: The Crescendo magnet system made
from 6 neodymium magnets providing excellent ventilation
for the voice coil. This -001 has not, rather a round neo
magnet making a non-vented cavity behind the voice coil.
So, you are getting something for the extra
money. But this is about it.

Right:
-001 added a felt pad similar to the -002. The
self-adhesive felt pad is 5 x 15 mm and sticks to the
foam plug leaving just ½ mm opening to the foam. I
rounded the felt pad slightly as can be seen from photo.
So, does it make a difference? Frequency response graphs
below. Red = + felt pad. Blue = as-is.

Builders' response
- go to
CNO built by Andrej -
- go to
CNO built by Terry -
- go to
CNO built by Kevin -
- go to
CNO built by Kjell -
|