|
Dear Troels,
Just three months ago, I received the TL-5 cabinets, built in 25 mm MDF
(30 mm for the woofer baffle) by MF Custom Speakers in Poland, following
Troels Gravesen's original drawings. The company is run by two young,
talented and highly motivated craftsmen, and throughout the entire
project we stayed in almost daily contact with smooth communication
through a dedicated WhatsApp group.
Only a few minor modifications were made to the original design. For
example, the side panels extend 16 mm beyond the front baffles to allow
perfectly flush-mounted speaker grilles (keep in mind that the mid
driver front chassis thickness is more than 15 mm).
The quality of the cabinets is outstanding. They are CNC-machined and
assembled with exceptional precision and craftsmanship. At my request,
MF Custom Speakers also arranged for the cabinets to be finished with a
premium automotive paint of my choice. Although significantly more
expensive than conventional lacquer, the result is clearly superior,
that fully justifies the additional cost. For shipping, the cabinets
were simply secured to a pallet, carefully wrapped and firmly strapped
down. Despite travelling all the way to Switzerland, they arrived in
absolutely perfect condition.
I opted for the passive version of the TL-5. The only significant
departure from Troels' original design was the choice of woofer. Instead
of the recommended unit, I selected the 18 Sound 18NLW9000, a driver
that is technically very similar but features a neodymium motor. I have
always preferred neodymium drivers whenever possible, and this project
was no exception.
Within a single weekend, both the crossovers and the loudspeakers were
fully assembled. The speakers were mounted on heavy-duty polyurethane
casters, raising them approximately 50 mm above the floor while allowing
them to be moved easily during the long process of finding their optimal
position.
The system was connected to my reference electronics: a Totaldac
d1-total streamer, di-reclocker, d1-sublime DAC, two d1-driver-sublime
passive preamplifiers, a Holton Inviso pure Class A amplifier delivering
50 W into 8 ohms for the midrange and treble, and two Holton Ex Nihilo
monoblocks producing 275 W into 8 ohms for the woofers. All
interconnects and speaker cables were custom-built.
One point should be made very clear: I was not immediately impressed.
Partly because one never quite knows what to expect from a loudspeaker
built around professional PA drivers. But also because my reference
loudspeakers are the TG Ellipticor 50 MKII, which are simply
extraordinary in virtually every respect. They excel in microdynamics,
possess astonishing refinement and transparency, and are built around
what is, in my opinion, one of the finest midrange drivers ever
produced.
My very first impression of the TL-5 was their astonishing macrodynamic
capability—something that genuinely takes time to adjust to. Equally
striking was their ability to reproduce music at sustained listening
levels of 95 to 100 dB without the slightest hint of distortion or
mechanical stress. Rather than sounding louder, they simply sounded
larger and more effortless.
Finding their ideal position required patience. After numerous
experiments in my 90 m² listening room, several small adjustments and,
most importantly, tilting the upper cabinet backwards by approximately
four degrees, I finally found the optimum setup. The loudspeakers now
form an equilateral triangle of 3.2 metres with the listening position,
are toed in by approximately 16 to 20 degrees, and have no nearby
boundaries, with the closest walls being about 2.7 metres away.
After more than three months of listening—time that also proved
beneficial for driver break-in—I now feel that the loudspeakers have
reached their full potential. The following impressions therefore
reflect not the excitement of a first encounter, but the conclusions
drawn after living with them over an extended period.
What immediately became apparent over the following weeks was that these
loudspeakers are remarkably difficult to analyse in the traditional
audiophile sense. Rather than drawing attention to individual aspects of
their performance, they present music as a coherent whole. One quickly
stops listening for bass extension, treble sparkle or imaging tricks,
and simply becomes absorbed in the performance itself. That, in my
opinion, is one of the rarest qualities a loudspeaker can possess.
The first characteristic that consistently stood out throughout all my
listening sessions was the extraordinary sense of effortlessness. At no
point do the loudspeakers give the impression that they are approaching
their mechanical or dynamic limits. Whether reproducing the explosive
crescendos of Hugh Masekela's Stimela, the intimacy of Patricia Barber's
Company or the acoustic realism of Nils Lofgren's Keith Don't Go, they
remain composed and completely unconstrained. Instead of sounding louder
as the music becomes more demanding, they simply sound larger. The
presentation expands naturally in scale, creating the impression of
virtually unlimited headroom.
Their macrodynamic capabilities are exceptional. Large orchestral
climaxes, powerful drum strikes and sudden dynamic contrasts are
reproduced with an authority that is rarely encountered, even among very
expensive loudspeakers. Yet this dynamic freedom never comes across as
aggressive or spectacular for its own sake. It simply feels natural, as
if the loudspeakers possess reserves that remain largely untapped.
Listening at sustained levels is therefore surprisingly comfortable,
because distortion never seems to become part of the musical experience.
Another characteristic that deserves particular mention is the
loudspeaker's remarkable consistency across different listening levels.
Many systems only come fully alive when played loudly, while others lose
composure as the volume increases. The TL-5 behaves differently. Whether
listening late at night at moderate levels or at realistic concert
levels, the tonal balance, spatial presentation and overall musical
expression remain essentially unchanged. At lower volumes, the
loudspeakers do not become thin, lifeless or dynamically compressed;
they simply reproduce the performance on a smaller scale. As the
listening level increases, the presentation gains physical impact and
authority, yet the fundamental character of the sound remains intact.
This ability to preserve both tonal integrity and emotional
communication regardless of playback level is, in my experience, one of
the clearest indicators of a genuinely accomplished loudspeaker
design.Equally impressive are the microdynamics. Small variations in
playing intensity, subtle vocal inflections, the delicate touch of
brushes on cymbals or the changing pressure of fingers on guitar strings
are reproduced with remarkable fidelity. Particularly on Keith Don't Go,
the guitar is rendered not only through its strings but as a complete
resonating instrument, preserving both the initial attack and the
harmonic decay of the wooden body. The loudspeakers follow every nuance
of the performance without ever sounding analytical or artificially
detailed.
The tonal balance is equally convincing. The bass reaches deep and
possesses considerable authority, yet never dominates the presentation.
It provides a solid foundation while remaining agile and exceptionally
well controlled. The midrange is arguably the greatest strength of the
system. Voices have natural body, warmth and physical presence without
sounding projected or oversized. Despite using professional drivers,
there is virtually no trace of the forward or aggressive character that
many listeners associate with PA-based loudspeakers.
The treble deserves particular praise. I had expected at least a slight
hint of the typical compression-driver signature, yet throughout all
three recordings I was repeatedly surprised by its refinement. Cymbals
retain their metallic shimmer without hardness, guitar harmonics extend
naturally, and reverberation decays effortlessly into silence.
High-frequency information is abundant, but never highlighted for
effect.
Transparency is another area where these loudspeakers excel. However,
they achieve it in a different way from many modern ultra-high-end
designs. They do not impress by exaggerating detail or dissecting
recordings into countless individual components. Instead, they simply
remove themselves from the signal. Complex passages remain intelligible
because distortion is evidently very low and each instrument preserves
its own identity within the musical structure. Details are always
present for those who choose to listen for them, but they never distract
from the musical performance.
The soundstage is equally convincing. Width is determined by the
recording itself rather than artificially expanded beyond the
loudspeakers. More remarkable is the sense of depth. Voices, instruments
and ambient information occupy clearly separated acoustic planes,
creating a believable three-dimensional perspective. The centre image
remains exceptionally stable, while musicians are reproduced as physical
bodies rather than sharply outlined cut-outs. Some loudspeakers produce
more holographic precision, but few reproduce such convincing physical
scale.
The impression of scale becomes even more evident with large orchestral
works. Listening to Mahler's Symphony No. 2 under Leonard Bernstein, the
TL-5 demonstrates an impressive ability to preserve order within an
exceptionally complex musical landscape. Even as the orchestra reaches
full strength, the presentation never collapses into a homogeneous wall
of sound. Individual orchestral families remain clearly identifiable,
with strings, woodwinds, brass and percussion occupying distinct
positions both laterally and, more importantly, in depth. The soundstage
grows naturally as the music develops, giving the orchestra convincing
physical dimensions rather than simply increasing in loudness. Equally
impressive is the loudspeaker's ability to communicate the architecture
of the performance. Bernstein's carefully constructed crescendos unfold
with remarkable inevitability, allowing musical tension to build
progressively without ever sounding strained or congested. Throughout
the recording, transparency and coherence remain intact, enabling the
listener to follow the orchestral dialogue even during the most
demanding passages. This ability to preserve musical structure while
maintaining effortless dynamics is, in my opinion, one of the defining
characteristics of the TL-5.
Perhaps the most surprising aspect of the TL-5 is its coherence. Despite
being a large multi-way loudspeaker built around professional
transducers, it behaves as a single acoustic source. At no point does
one become consciously aware of individual drivers or crossover
transitions. Everything emerges with remarkable continuity, giving the
impression of listening to one instrument rather than several
transducers working together.
After living with these loudspeakers for several months and evaluating
them with recordings ranging from intimate jazz and solo acoustic guitar
to large-scale orchestral works, I have come to the conclusion that
their greatest strength is not any individual performance parameter, but
their remarkable ability to preserve musical structure, tonal coherence
and dynamic freedom regardless of the complexity of the programme
material. They combine the effortlessness and headroom of the finest
professional monitoring systems with the refinement and musicality
expected from very high-end domestic loudspeakers. Rather than
impressing through spectacular hi-fi effects, they recreate the scale,
flow and emotional impact of live music with an ease that allows the
listener to forget the loudspeakers altogether. Based solely on their
musical performance, I have no hesitation in placing the TL-5 in the
company of loudspeakers retailing in the €50,000–60,000 range. Not
because of luxurious cabinetry or exotic materials, but because of the
sheer quality of their musical reproduction. In the end, that may well
be the highest compliment any loudspeaker can receive.
Ultimately, no written review can replace a personal listening
experience. Those interested are warmly invited to audition the TL-5 in
a purpose-designed listening studio located just 12 minutes from Basel
EuroAirport, at the crossroads of Switzerland, France and Germany. For
added perspective, the TL-5 can also be compared directly with the TG’s
Ellipticor 50 MKII in the same room and with the same electronics.
Troels, many thanks for you design and help !
Cheers,
Theo

























|