The Importance of Chamfering Driver Holes
Copyright 2009 Troels Gravesen

This study has been on the to-do list ever since I saw the first Avalon clones with the middriver stuck into a very narrow and deep rectangular hole. I always thought the midrange would suffer congestion but I never had the chance to hear any of the clones.

As often as possible I stress the importance of chamfering the driver holes to allow free ventilation for the rear energy coming from the driver. Obviously the energy coming from the rear of the driver is exactly the same as what comes from the front and as most drivers have very thin and acoustically transparent membranes we need to do all we can to get rid of the rear energy in order not to have that energy being reflected back towards the membrane. The reflected rear energy will be delayed and hitting the membrane it will cause smearing of detail and increased (subjective) distortion.

Set-up:
33 liter test cabinet with lots of damping material (MDM3).
Front panel = 30 x 50 cm.
Driver placed on center, 20 cm from top.
Driver: SEAS CA12RC, flush mounted.

I was sure the differences would show up on CSD (cumulative spectral decay) and step response, but it didn't. Much to my surprise! But what surprised me even more was that it had a significant impact on frequency response. What I already knew from mounting a small middriver into a narrow tube (A) was the impact on sound (TJL3W and Classic 3-Way). Comparing A and C on pink noise leave no doubt of the importance of chamfering driver holes. On C we hear a full-bodied sound with deep and wide low-end response where A will make the sound thin with an unpleasant presence. It sounds congested.

 


The various scenarios. D and E were not tested after having tested A-B-C.


Left: Two 22 mm MDF sheets were used for study. Right: 22 mm/no chamfering.


Left: 22 mm/45 deg. chamfering. Right: 44 mm/no chamfering.


Frequency response from A red), B (blue) and C (green). Right: 5 dB scaling 100-10000 Hz.


Left: Distortion from situation A. Right: Distortion from situation C. Distortion raised 15 dB. No apparent differences.
Blue = 2nd harm., green = 3rd harm., yellow = 4th harm., purple = 5th harm.


22 mm front panel without chamfering.


22 mm front panel with chamfering.


44 mm front panel without chamfering.

Worst case


This is the worst example I've seen from a commercial speaker, System Audio 1750.
Due to the thick front panel and magnetic shield these drivers certainly can't breathe. Hardly optimal.


Here's an even worse example. I hope this ~4" transmission line is part of the equation.